order hcg nolvadex nolvadex buy buy nolvadex nolvadex buy order nolvadex buying nolvadex purchase nolvadex order hcg nolvadex buy nolvadex estrogen blocker buy nolvadex online nolvadex 20 mg dose nolvadex without prescription nolvadex 20 mg scored nolvadex guarantee delivery nolvadex no prescription how many mg are nolvadex tabs nolvadex guarantee delivery nolvadex 30 day supply price how many mg are nolvadex tabs nolvadex without prescription buy nolvadex estrogen blocker where to buy nolvadex and clomid research and buy nolvadex online nolvadex proviron no prescription do i need a prescription for nolvadex

DEBATING DIFFERENT TYPES OF FANDOM


Throughout my life I’ve been both types of fan, loyalist and leach, depending on the sport. There is logic and even romance in each. But as I age I’m attracted more and more to the latter, to the Chuck Klosterman sort of sports fandom that resembles musical taste – polygamous and fickle. I think this is common for a lot of modern sports fans, the mass consumers of entertainment that we are. But such anti-affiliation, although aesthetically pleasing and easy, undercuts some of the most fundamental aspects of fandom no matter how much it tries to objectify a sport.

The trend toward changeable fandom parallels social trends. Simon Kuper and Stefan Szymanski don’t say this explicitly, but seem to imply it in an extract from their new book, Why England Lose: And Other Curious Football Phenomena Explained. They show, using numbers that seem a little dubious, how loyalist fans (whom they call Hornby-types in reference to Nick Hornby’s classic Fever Pitch) are actually a rare breed in modern British society despite stubborn myths to the contrary. They suggest that modern mobility of place and class cause changing devotions. They also suggest that such mobility causes the myth of the Hornby-type to persist. Rootlessness prompts a reactive nostalgia, a desire for an authenticity and identity that isn’t there.
http://10000118.tbpcontrol.co.uk/TBP.Control/ShopImages/10000118/Nick%20Hornby%20Fever%20Pitch.jpg
Like the authors say, “fandom is not a static condition but a process.” Changing affiliation can come as a natural part of our development. As impressionable youths we latch onto a team with all our starry-eyed might. We crave idols and identity and acceptance and a professional team overflows with these things. That, or our dads make sure that a certain baseball team came as part of our genetic code. So we are loyal, at least for a while. But as we grow, more mobile and more discerning about our tastes, we feel freer to change affiliations. We realize that rootless fandom is easier and a lot less painful than unconditional devotion. Our fandom depends on taste, on the style we relate to or the players we like. Or it depends on convenience, where we are and when. It depends on us, not on the randomized geography of birthplace or our father’s heavy-handed indoctrination via the bed sheets he bought for us on our fourth birthday. This is how I watch most soccer, free and easy. And I’ve always believed it has given me objectivity, more sensitivity to the nature of the game because I’m not biased to the trivialities of one team . It’s not necessarily about the result. I route for good soccer and the teams that play it.

I’ve tried to adopt many foreign teams over the years, not just for their aesthetics. As a kid I liked Nottingham Forest because it sounded like some sort of fantastical place where goals grew along with the moss and trees. Since 2004, I’ve routed for Manchester City, after I told a Manchunian friend that I would adopt City if he adopted my then hapless Boston Red Sox. I tried to convince myself of my City fandom. I always liked Claudio Reyna, I reasoned. I liked the way City were a second-fiddle team in a soccer mad city with a first rate fan base. I liked that they had history. I felt like I owed it to City after the Red Sox won the World Series. I still say I like them, mostly to piss off fans of the other Big Four teams, and to keep appeasing the Sports Gods. But it never felt authentic.

No matter which club I try to adopt, foreign or American, something is missing. What attachment do I have to a club thousands of miles away? How much do I really know about their history, their pain? It’s in these questions that the loyalists have us beat, even if their attachment traces back to time they spent watching a certain team with an otherwise negligent dad – especially if it traces back to this. There are old world values in unconditional loyalty. You love a team like you love a father or wife, in sickness and in health, alcoholism or betrayal. Sometimes you don’t even know why you love them. You just do. They chose you.

The only soccer team I’ve ever supported unconditionally has been the U.S. national team. It has been painful. Occasionally glorious, but mostly painful, even when we squeak out wins against Trinidad and Tobago. But I feel invested in my fandom, in my infinitesimal stake in the team. I know the team’s history, its faults and its potential for success. But most importantly, I know what it feels like to truly route for them, to be crushed and then hopeful, over and over. Such devotion, as foolish or false as it can be, ties us to our surroundings – to our neighbors, to the communities and countries where we live. Loyal fandom helps us pare down the swirling and infinite chaos of the world, even the soccer world, to something we can hold onto and make sense of, to one game at a time, to wins and losses. We can see and feel the game in a way that means something to us, or at least means more than its entertainment value.
http://www.instablogsimages.com/images/2007/10/30/fans-of-manchester-united-sporting-a-tattoo_6874.jpg
I think this is what separates sports from art or other entertainment fields. Although fans obviously want to be entertained, sports rely on a different value system than say music. Competition, or the idea of winning and losing, lies at the heart of any sport’s worth. Although winning can serve as one function of entertainment, it also serves as a value system that functions separately from, often in opposition to, a game’s style or capacity to entertain – however much us unaffiliated wish it didn’t. As much as fans follow sports be entertained, we also watch to feel the ecstasy and despair and hatred that wins and losses cause. We can’t feel the drama of the sport fully unless we attach some sort of loyalty to our fandom. The more loyalty, the greater the payoff or the let down. Without loyalty we lose the fundamental aspect of investment (economic and emotional and physical) in the teams we follow. We get stadiums muted by shrugging critics with pursed lips, polite and ultimately feckless. We get lower highs and higher lows.

I’m as responsible for this as anyone. But I hope I’m not representative of of too big of a trend. Otherwise we’re turning into a society of squabbling philosophers who don’t know what it means to be xenophobic toward “other” people for no reason. And where’s the fun in that?◊

Thanks to fredorrarci for compiling the quality pieces that spurred this belated post.

, , , , , , , , ,

  1. #1 by Ryan - September 15th, 2009 at 21:13

    I completely agree with you.

    I’ve tried to choose a team with which to align, but find it impossible without local context. I end up watching the games with the best possible chance for quality play and find my affinity or distaste revolving around individuals. Ultimately, I want both.

    I live in Chicago and rooting for the Fire while trying to enjoy the game is impossible.

    I should just move to Europe.

  2. #2 by h-bomb - September 15th, 2009 at 22:21

    It is style. Think of no jerseys, no ads, no stadium, no lines…what do you see: the —-, and your team. what do you dream of who playing with where. Hornby talks about family. family. (that book is kinda crazy…dude shoots up arsenal) yo. hate on haters. love on lovers. and hate on lovers of lovers without love. i just got re-inspired.

    peaks and…..peaks. support effort. don’t move to europe ryan, its overrated.

  3. #3 by Sean - September 16th, 2009 at 16:48

    I clearly remember the evening I realized that all the history in the world didn’t mean much to my fickle aesthete soul. I was sitting in the basement of my parents’ house (which makes sense, as I was about 12 at the time), watching the twice-annual Purdue-Indiana basketball matchup – propped up, as it happens, by the gold-and-black Boilermaker pillows my mother fashioned during the long dark winters, and surrounded by my mothers’ family, Purdue supporters all. I was raised in gold and black clothing.

    And yet, and yet … that 1980 Indiana team played basketball the way I dreamed it: Fluid but intense, opportunistic yet fair. They had a guy who’d grown up about 30 miles away. And I sat there in silence, rooting for the team that played beautifully over the team that I was, literally, raised to believe in.

    In some ways I envy Hornby-types their arias. But for me, the passion must serve the beauty. I’m a fugue guy.

(will not be published)
Listed on Soccer Blogs

build a mousetrap car

john denver muppets

do people relocate with no jobs

a separate peace 1972

how does the voice box wo

i am the warlock

vbhma.com

12 step program printed in spanish

duchess perfume

mini nubian goats for sale

all inclusive kos greece

american national ins company

didik.com

advertising franchise opportunity

3.5 sp1 no windows update

bern info

halfway house cky

50 most common drinks bartender

2006 nae4ha conference

boastful chinen yuri

hotel guide in rimini italy

caring for icu vent patients

brethren village neffsville

cheapest zelda ocarina to buy

exquisiteimagesphotography.com

cannon elf 1100

brushing teeth with salt

art-hanoi.com

free christmas ornaments needlepoint cross stitch

mmoworld.com

buy stir fry sauces

securesure.net

casting crowns in the wrong direction

360drives.com

crab meat stuffed ravioli recipe

1800 s style clothing

anika morton

alaskan malamute rescue

10 electric fry pan farberware

cht denise of kirkland wa

bug listening devices

abel pliers cabela

mythbusters collection

afghan headgear

add to remove too sweet taste

disciplines of discourse analysis and pragmatics

fractal imager

are lories good companion pets

cassie anna laprade

batch downloader

holy apostles seminary

myskindesigncontest.com

leia meeker

australian building societies

cemetery kiosk

proof of derivitive of tangent

12 step cafe

catherine burroughs mattson burlington iowa

penske cherry hill

gathering truffles california

accord brake locked

acker paving

native american music smithsonian

blowjobs in bleachers

atmospheric glow discharge

securesitehome.com

educacion primaria actividades educativas

astrology loves

delcastle vo tech

detroit tv ministers

average sunny days in greentown pa

1st way az

christmas teas at hotels

family reunion reunions 2008 2009

abetta saddles deluxe trail saddle

all in wonder radon drivers

rebuild-from-depression.com

brinkmann 6345

basic hindu words

bucker 181 in minn

900 series bowling early

1976 motto guzzi parts

mongolian archers

fujitsu ac adapter sale

ohiocul.org

balu pharmacy stirling

blue lizard poker

algae outside walls

bad human parasites

earthportals.com

evergreen shrubs

akai mpc wav

dandy camp saws

common sense sash pulley

bid a wee

1999 altima catalytic coverter is bad

german real agenda behind kyoto

button robes

2007 state cup soccer omaha tranquility

accomodation requirement oregon employers smoking

mark holleran san antonio texas messianic

bonnanza utube

ken lowry lakers

embarassing erections

folie a deux pavlove download

jeu sega

defiance county ohio 1860 map

cherish the ladies an irish homecoming

camp saginaw

wrhs.net

darth maul saboteur james luceno

compliant department for colombian emerald international

teencathouse.com

acupuncturists perform spinal manipulation

5 themes of geography mr lip

1984 country coach diesel pusher

cast opf csi

abdomen pain and hard

1989 bmw 325i antenna mast

dvdflick.net

3day bake sale recipe ideas

maris studios lindos

caravan centre taunton ku

10th edition artwork spoiler complete

craiglist albany ga

kkk adkins louisiana

caviar how to eat

3-d dolls

outrageous modern king beds

helen ellis hosp

heike sefrin weis

pakistani aunty divorce

babies ears nonsymmetrical

attractions near wildwood fl

2000 ford explorer highway vibration drone

408 chrysler crank

alhambra dinner jax fl

bush bobble head

big biography on elijah w

bk home moss similarity randy

wingate 6.2.1 serial

askdex.com

cheapest airfares to honduras

2005 dodge caravan spark plugs

chemist direct uk

carmelite monastery santa clara

golfers that are dead and woman

anit federalist papers

carp camp robinson

el segundo california vacation homes

custom dodge one ton dually

bariatric surgery patients in icu

04 celica pics

trophytroutguide.com

cadets anual camp

80s songs about robots

emergent transitional intermediate advanced writers

horner butterfly

narrow urethra symptoms

inflamation arachidonic

cannondale base long sleeve